Phish flop. The City Club of Chicago is a civic organization that caters to those interested in government and business – but apparently the group does not include many fans of the band Phish. During his speech at a City Club luncheon Tuesday, Chicago Park District General Superintendent and CEO Michael Kelly told the audience that Jimmy Buffet and Phish are playing shows at Northerly Island this summer. When Kelly asked how many Phish fans were in the room, he was met with mostly silence and some muffled laughter.